Monday, May 15, 2017

Results and The Imperiled Poppets Bracket (Round 3)

Look. I bit the bullet. There was only one tie this week and it was between a book I cannot explain why I adore--Winter Wedding (I think that these books that you read early get stuck in your brain and there is no rational explanation of one's love of them thereafter.)--and a book that has one of my favorite scenes in all of Neelsdom, Matilda's Wedding. Fate, indeed, is remarkable. It's a great hulking bully who kicks people in the shins, that's what.
Week by week, her favorites were falling...

Here are the results of the latest round of voting. As you can see, I moved Fate is Remarkable into a match up.


Henrietta's Own Castle vs.
Fate is Remarkable
Mathilda's Wedding vs.
Only By Chance
A Dream Came True vs.
bye--no contest this week



It was with a good deal of angst that I chose Matilda's Wedding. But I am going to make myself tedious about why I love Winter Wedding and everyone is just going to listen and not argue. 

  • First, the improvident application of too much Elizabeth Arden blusher. 
  • Second, the moment that happens off-screen when Renier can't sleep and finds himself outside a pawn shop in the early morning buying a locket of all things for a girl he doesn't even like.
  • Third, Renier is really good with kids.
  • Fourth, Emily rescues Granny! Really heroically. Renier wants her desperately, owes her big time and STILL can't close the deal.
  • Fifth, Emily keeps her entire extended family running with a homicidal maniac as a mother's help.
  • Sixth, Grandma Jurres-Romeijn trying to bribe her with the family jewels and failing.
I knew it wasn't going to win. Heck, it wouldn't win even if I was the only one voting. But just let me be sad, okay?
Yes. Fine. I'll lose to Chris Pine.
He should give me a hug.

Alright, now that I've worked through my considerable issues, we're on to The Imperiled Poppets Bracket (Round 3)!

11 comments:

  1. The voting is getting to the tail end now and there are difficult choices ahead. The first because it truly brings a tear to my eye each time I read it. The second I love because most dislike it with a vengeance but I love a man who knows how to grovel. The third one I adore as our heroine is not fooled by the ogre and the fourth because he's such a grouch and can't stop thinking about the heroine, so I like his POV.

    The Secret Pool
    The Hasty Marriage
    Cassandra by Chance
    Roses Have Thorns
    The Promise of Happiness

    ReplyDelete
  2. The Secret Pool

    The Hasty Marriage

    Cassandra By Chance

    Roses Have Thorns

    The Promise of Happiness

    ReplyDelete
  3. Secret Pool
    Discovering Daisy
    Cassandra by Chance
    Damsel in Green
    Promise of Happiness

    Super easy voting this week! I didn't even have to refer back to my previous notes.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Betty Barbara here, pleased as punch that 'Matilda's Wedding' survived.
    This bracket, though, sigh...

    The Secret Pool
    The Hasty Marriage
    Tabitha by Moonlight
    Roses Have Thorns
    Promise of Happiness (bye)

    I had problems with this bracket. I dislike Secret Pool, but I really dislike Little Dragon. I love Tabitha, I love Cassandra. So I was forced to vote for a book I dislike and vote against a book I love, just because of the bracket maker. Sigh...
    At least the other two choices were easier for me.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Another two of my choices wiped out. Do I see a system here? 😺

    The Secret Pool
    The Hasty Marriage
    Cassandra By Chance
    Damsel in Green

    The Promise of Happiness vs.
    bye--no match this week

    This was sooooooooooooo easy. The only pair that gave me pause was the first, and I actually changed my mind and went with The Secret Pool, after all.

    ReplyDelete
  6. The Secret Pool
    Discovering Daisy
    Cassandra by Chance
    Roses Have Thorns
    The Promise of Happiness (bye)

    Cassandra v Tabitha was really the only angsty choice for me this week.

    Also, I just want to say to Betty Keira that I acknowledge the sacrifice you made in breaking the tie between WW and MW. Like The Hasty Marriage, WW is one of those books that elicits strong feelings, both pro and con.

    ReplyDelete
  7. The Secret Pool
    Discovering Daisy
    Cassandra by Chance
    Damsel in Green

    I'm with Betty Barb - the first match up was pick the one I dislike less; the third Huuuurtz! Tabitha - oh, Tabitha.

    And may I say, again, how brilliant the bracket titles are? Because they are very, very brilliant.

    ReplyDelete
  8. The Little Dragon
    The Hasty Marriage
    Cassandra By Chance
    Roses Have Thorns
    The Promise of Happiness

    ReplyDelete
  9. Secret Pool
    Hasty Marriage
    Tabitha in Moonlight
    Damsel in Green
    Promise of Happiness

    Oh wow, this was a hard one. I love the ogre, but have to go with Tabitha in Moonlight because oil stained shorts. Nothing more than oil stained shorts. Even an ogre can't top that.

    Secret Pool and Little Dragon was a hard decision too. I finally went with Secret Pool because I love the fact that our heroine makes the little girl a stuff mouse, dressed as a bride. Such a Neels thing to do! Damsel in Green vs. Roses have Thorns was another hard choice. I'm not too enamored of either Hasty Marriage or Discovering Daisy but it still wasn't easy.

    The only easy choice was The Promise of Happiness, and that was because nothing was competing against it :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The Promise of Happiness would ALWAYS be an easy choice for me, because it wins everything.

      Delete
  10. Secret Pool
    Discovering Daisy
    Tabitha
    Roses have Thorns

    Count me in with the people who don't like either Secret Pool or Little Dragon, wish we could have re-vamped the choices a bit.

    ReplyDelete